Major Sovereign Wealth Funds Deals through January 2008

According to Thompson Financial via Gulf News:

 

Economist cover story: ‘Invasion of the Sovereign Wealth Funds’

The Economist’s cover story this week is a feature on Sovereign Wealth Funds.

The story gives a good overview of many of the basics such as size of SWFs, how they came about, how they’ve evolved, where they’re headed, and the issues facing SWF investing. It also includes a relatively balanced discussion on the motives of SWFs, which isn’t surprising as The Economist is probably the most fair and balanced mainstream publication around.

One point that The Economist makes, that has been completely absent from the mainstream debate thus far, is that the fear of politicizing foreign investments cuts both ways. The SWFs must be cognizant of possible retaliatory actions, such as asset freezes and/or asset confiscations, that can be taken against their investments for things such as political disagreements or court rulings that hold SWFs responsible for the actions of their host country’s citizens. The Economist cites the example of Britain forcing the Kuwait Investment Authority to divest from part of its’ stake in BP in the 1980s because Margaret Thatcher, in the midst of privatizing national assets, ‘was in no mood to see so much of a national treasure owned by a foreign government’.

Politicians scrutinizing the recent flurry of SWF investments should take care to remember that these infusions are in effect rescue capital that their government’s would likely be on the hook for had SWFs been deterred from investing, and that their own future geopolitical motives should be held to the same standard they want to hold SWFs to.

The article concludes, correctly in my opinion, by saying the chief threat that SWFs pose is that of financial protectionism and that it’s in the best interests of all parties to get along:

The hope is that both host countries and sovereign-wealth funds see that their interest lies in building confidence. The hosts stand to benefit from the funds’ capital. Meanwhile the funds are ruled by the politics of the places where they invest. You are only sovereign at home; abroad, someone else wields the power.

Most Notable Sovereign Wealth Fund Deals of 2007

2007 was the year sovereign wealth funds put themselves on the map. In order to understand the evolution of SWFs, it’s obligatory to take a critical look at some of the landmark events of that important year. Expect to see more 2007 reviews, commentaries, and analytical pieces in the comings weeks. To kick things off, a review of the most newsworthy SWF deals of 2007:

• Dec. 24, 2007: Merrill Lynch says it will sell a stake in itself of at least $4.4 billion, and up to $5 billion, to Singapore’s state-run Temasek Holdings. Temasek will hold less than 10 percent of Merrill and have no voting control. Merrill also agreed to sell a $1.2 billion stake to domestic investors

• Dec. 10, 2007: UBS AG announces that the Government of Singapore Investment Corp., a sovereign-wealth fund, is investing $9.75 billion for a 9 percent stake in the Swiss banking giant, while an undisclosed strategic investor in the Middle East is contributing $1.77 billion in UBS AG.

• Nov. 26, 2007: Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, the sovereign investment fund of the Gulf Arab state, acquires a 4.9 percent stake in Citigroup Inc., the largest U.S. bank, for $7.5 billion.

• Nov. 7, 2007: Central Huijin Investment Co., China’s largest state-owned investment arm, acquires 71 percent of China’s joint-stock China Everbright Bank for $2.7 billion.

• Oct. 29, 2007: Dubai International Capital, owned by Dubai-ruler Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, acquires 9.9 percent outstanding equity stake in Och-Ziff Capital Management Group, a U.S.-based hedge fund, for more than $1.1 billion. Och-Ziff goes public in November on the New York Stock Exchange.

• Oct. 22, 2007: China’s government-controlled Citic Securities Co. and U.S. investment bank Bear Stearns Cos. agree to invest $1 billion in each other for minority stakes that could be expanded. They will also operate a 50-50 joint venture in Hong Kong to offer capital markets services across Asia.

• Sept. 20, 2007: The Qatar Investment Authority, Qatar’s sovereign investment fund, acquires a 20 percent stake in the London Stock Exchange and nearly 10 percent of Nordic bourse operator OMX AB.

• Sept. 20, 2007: Abu Dhabi-based Mubadala Development Co., an investment arm of the Abu Dhabi government, buys a 7.5 percent stake of the management operations of one of the world’s largest private-equity firms, Carlyle Group, for $1.35 billion

• July 23, 2007: China Development Bank, a Chinese state agency, agrees to pay $3 billion for a 3.1 percent stake in British bank Barclays PLC, and Temasek Holdings, a sovereign wealth fund in Singapore, agrees to pay $2 billion for a 1.77 percent stake in Barclays.

• July 13, 2007: Dubai International Capital purchases a 2.87 percent stake in one of India’s largest banks, ICICI Bank Ltd., for $750 million.

• May 20, 2007: China’s state investment company agrees to pay $3 billion for a 10 percent stake in U.S. private equity firm Blackstone Group LP. The Chinese investment company agreed to buy nonvoting shares in Blackstone concurrent with Blackstone’s initial public offering.

• May 2, 2007: Dubai International Capital buys a undisclosed stake in British bank HSBC Holdings PLC.

Weekend Links (13 January 2008)

Some recent stories of interest:

• Gulf States to stay on trail of foreign companies: (Financial Times)
• A Closer Look at Sovereign Wealth Funds – Secretive, Powerful, And Huge: (Knowledge @ Wharton)
• Buffet says he turned down investments in financials: (Bloomberg)
• Sovereign funds invest where Buffet won’t: (Bloomberg)
• China and the Arabian Peninsula as market stabilizers: (Stratfor)
• The price of oil and nationalism: (Economist)
• Canada is ‘anxious’ to have investment from China: (Bloomberg)
• No sovereign wealth fund for Canada: (Bloomberg)
• Bush’s “New Middle East”: (Time)
• Abu Dhabi – East Leans West: (City Journal)
• The Dubai phenomenon: (Bitterlemons-international.org)
• How Arab Countries are Coping with Globalization: (Knowledge @ Wharton)
• Can the Middle East Sustain Democracy?: (Middle East Strategy at Harvard)
• The Arabs should stop whining: (Haaretz)
• Sovereign Wealth Funds making ‘good’ investments in US banks: (Emirates Business 24/7)
• Americans sold out to foreign firms at record rate: (Bloomberg)